At Sheets Insurance, we combine expertise with honesty and integrity to guide you toward coverage that truly fits. No pressure, no hidden agendas—just independent, ethical advice you can trust every step of the way.

Kyle Sheets

Chief Executive Officer

Calvin Sheets

Senior Advisor

Jennifer Poage

Agent

Gail Ronneburger

Customer Service Representative

Ronessa Joseph

Customer Service Representative

Christopher Phillips Professional Picture

Chris Phillips

Agent

Nicole Boyett

Agent

Lydia Lewis

Agent

See Why Our Customers Love Us

      EXCELLENT  
   Based on 369 reviews 
    
 
 
 
   
 
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Cameron Smith 
 6 November 2026
 
 
  Jennifer is extremely helpful, she was able to get us great coverage at a great price. I’ve been working with her for years now, she is amazing.
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   Barbara Dooley 
 5 November 2026
 
 
  Great agency ! Best price, quick and efficient !
T. Dooley
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   Robyn Darlow 
 3 November 2026
 
 
  Love Kyle and his team at Sheet Insurance!  Always looking out for my family's best interests with both my car and homeowners insurance.
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   Charles Ferrara 
 2 November 2026
 
 
  My insurance Agent is Lydia Lewis, ahe is excellent to work with. She answered all my questions , helped me get the right coverage for myslef & my car. She worjed with me throughout the process. . I will gladly call her again next time I have any insurance need or questions
  
 
     Posted on Google  
   
   Olesya Sheptytska 
 31 October 2026
 
 
  Great experience with Sheets Insurance Agency. Specifically I am working with Chris Phillips, he is super helpful, very knowledgable, very supportive with many ideas. I just moved to DE and he did a great job assisting me with right insurance according to my needs. Would definitely recommend.